Post Info TOPIC: Who wrote these lihes?
Helen Brooks

Date:
Who wrote these lihes?
Permalink Closed


A university press in Melbourne, Australia, wrote to me asking if I know who wrote these lines?  They were told the lines were written by John Donne, but they have not been able to locate the text.  I have asked other Donne scholars about the lines, and the guesses range from George Herbert to Edgar Guest.   The lines don't remind me of Donne,, but they indeed may be hidden away somewhere in his work.  Please let us know if the lines ring familiar.


                                       No hand did aid him, and he aided none.


                                       Alone he breasted the broad wave, alone


                                                       That man was saved.


 


Helen Brooks


 


 



__________________
Mark Allinson

Date:
Permalink Closed

Helen, the words you quote are from Thomas Shadwell's The Libertine.

Google tells me that Coleridge discusses this scene in B.L. -

click here

Perhaps the connection to Donne was made because the character is "Don John".

Regards.

Mark.



__________________
Helen Brooks

Date:
Permalink Closed

Dear Mark,


Wonderful!  Thank you so much.  The "Don Juan" connection is intriguing.


The scholar, who lives in Melbourne, said the lines appeared in a diary in 1947 by a French writer, Henri Thomas.  It seems that Thomas attributed the lines to Donne.  Her doctoral dissertation, completed at London University,  focused on his correspondence.  I have written her about the Donne website and your reply.



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard